Savannah River – Savannah Unplugged http://www.billdawers.com Mon, 04 Nov 2013 22:17:23 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 18778551 Will billions in East Coast port spending bring more trade through the Panama Canal? http://www.billdawers.com/2013/10/29/will-billions-in-east-coast-port-spending-bring-more-trade-through-the-panama-canal/ Tue, 29 Oct 2013 22:38:23 +0000 http://www.billdawers.com/?p=6326 Read more →

]]>

I’ve read a lot and written some over the last couple of years about the likely impacts on commerce of the Panama Canal expansion and the vast infrastructure spending in the U.S. to expand ports.

And I’m pretty cynical about the whole picture that’s emerging.

From the first, the Corps of Engineers’ study here in Savannah predicted that the amount of cargo handled at the Georgia ports would increase at the same rate over the next 20 years whether we dredged the river more deeply or did not. The logic is pretty simple, if not intuitive: If we dredge, we’ll see fewer but larger ships; if we don’t dredge, we will see more but smaller ships.

The Corps’ economic study said that the Savannah Harbor Expansion Project (SHEP) would be worth the massive expenditure of tax money because the deeper harbor and larger ships would make shipping companies more efficient. The attendant private savings would then appear elsewhere in the economy.

Side note: so ironic to see opponents of the 2009 stimulus and opponents of infrastructure spending by local governments support this massive federal infrastructure project.

Another side note: there are significant environmental risks here, and all the risk is being assumed at the local level. Will the benefits be local? According to the Corps’ economic study, there’s no way to answer that question. Since the savings will directly accrue to the shipping companies, the benefits could appear at any point in the supply chain.

Another side note: even dredged to 47′, the Savannah River will still be more shallow than several other key East Coast ports.

Of course, Savannah isn’t the only port likely to some massive spending for expansion, dredging, etc.

As more shipping experts and economists have considered all the impacts of the Panama Canal expansion, the more questions they seem to be raising about the likely impacts.

There is a growing number of voices who think that we won’t see a major redrawing of commerce. West Coast ports, according to this reasoning, will probably remain the first option for Asian shippers.

From an interesting report yesterday on NPR, Eastern Ports Spend Billions, But Will New Ships Come? by Greg Allen:

ALLEN: Economically speaking, there’s little question that modernizing ports and improving infrastructure is a good investment. But there are some in the cargo and logistics industry who now question whether the Panama Canal expansion will be the game changer that [Fla. Governor Rick] Scott, other public officials and port executives say it is.

ED SANDS: The fact is, they didn’t build it big enough.

ALLEN: Ed Sands is with Procurian. He spent decades in the logistics business, essentially helping companies move goods from point A to point B. The global recession brought big changes to the shipping industry. Sands says carriers are moving to a new class of mega-cargo ship – ships too large to go through the expanded Panama Canal.

SANDS: Technology and the developments in ship design and the massive chase for efficiency on behalf of the ocean carriers has rendered the canal expansion – I wouldn’t want to say it’s sort of a dud, but it’s not nearly as valuable had it been enlarged another 30 or 40 percent.

There are obviously more optimistic voices in the piece, but all have skin in the game, of one sort or another. Worth a listen:

]]>
6326
Growing uncertainty about future shipping patterns when Panama Canal expansion is completed http://www.billdawers.com/2013/08/30/growing-uncertainty-about-future-shipping-patterns-when-panama-canal-expansion-is-completed/ Fri, 30 Aug 2013 16:14:56 +0000 http://www.billdawers.com/?p=6115 Read more →

]]>

I’ve been spending a lot of time over the last couple of years reading about TEUs, about hub-and-spoke models for cargo transport, about tidal delays, about canal tolls, and on and on and on

With the widened Panama Canal likely to open the way for much larger ships around 2015, it’s clear that most East Coast U.S. ports will not even be able to accommodate some very large ships. And it’s becoming less clear by the day precisely what will happen from there.

The Corps of Engineers’ economic analysis of the Savannah Harbor Expansion Project, which would deepen the Savannah River to 47′ from 42′, found that the amount of cargo coming into the port would increase by the same rate for the next couple of decades no matter whether the river was deepened or not. The deeper channel would result in some dramatic cost savings, however — those savings would boost the economy in a variety of ways.

But many simply don’t believe that the Savannah port would see as much cargo if the river isn’t dredged. If those people are right, then it seems increasingly likely that the approved 47′ depth will be nowhere near deep enough for the Georgia ports to compete with deeper channels that are closer to the open ocean.

If you’re into wonky stuff like this, I highly recommend this post at DredgingToday.com: Dredging – Key Factor for US Container Port Call Strategies. From that piece:

Where the maritime community seems to have reached a fair consensus is on the size of the ships that will be deployed on All-Water Asia/US East Coast (USEC) through Panama (AWP) services. Once the widened Canal opens, ship sizes are anticipated to increase quickly from the current average 4,500 TEU up to around 8,000 TEU – similar to the size of ships presently deployed on All-Water Suez (AWS) services. There is also general agreement that despite the considerable increase in ship size and the respective reduction in shipping costs, the AWP route is likely to see only a modest increase in market share relative to its main rivals, the AWS and the US West Coast (USWC) landbridge.

Where opinions start to diverge more sharply is on the impact of Canal expansion on carriers’ North American service patterns and, especially, whether the present approach based mainly on direct port calls will be replaced, at least in part, by a hub and spoke system. […]

But, the locks of the expanded Panama Canal are designed for New-Panamax (NPX) ships, which are forecast to initially have capacity of 13,500 TEU and eventually 15,000 TEU. Following worldwide trends, it is quite likely that NPX will be deployed on AWP as well as on AWS services within 5 years or so following the expansion. Interestingly, this possibility was considered unlikely in channel-deepening studies undertaken by the US Army Corps of Engineers, the Federal agency in charge of US ports’ channels. Accordingly, the design ship for these channels is just 8,000 TEU! The Corps also dismissed the possibility that in the longer term, ships bigger than NPX, such as the 18,000 TEU Maersk Triple-Es recently deployed on the Asia-Europe trade, could be used on AWS services; and that in the even longer future ship size may reach the 28,000 TEU Malacca-Max (MLX).

It is not unfeasible that that introduction of ships too large for USEC ports’ newly-dredged channels will trigger a change in the service pattern of both AWP and AWS to hub and spoke. In this case, USEC ports would find themselves served by feeder services based on foreign hubs in the Caribbean region for AWP and Canada for AWS. This change in service pattern could be avoided by further deepening of USEC ports’ channels. However, considering the arduous process of the recent deepening projects, the prospects for this happening look pretty dim.

]]>
6115
Analyst suggests little immediate impact of Panama Canal expansion on East Coast ports http://www.billdawers.com/2013/08/14/business-insider-panama-canal-expansion-might-not-impact-east-coast-immediately/ Wed, 14 Aug 2013 16:09:49 +0000 http://www.billdawers.com/?p=6068 Read more →

]]>

From the Jacksonville Business Insider’s Panama Canal expansion might not impact East Coast immediately:

Mark Szakonyi, an associate editor with the Journal of Commerce and former Business Journal logistics reporter, […] spoke Monday to Jacksonville’s Council of Supply Chain Management Professionals on the state of the logistics/transportation industry. One topic he covered was how the canal widening will affect the East Coast. Not all analysts believe ports will miss out on a bonanza of trade if their shipping channels aren’t deepened by 2015, he said.

Some believe the cargo that would transition from West Coast ports to the East Coast has already come. If there’s any more to come, it will be in the low single digits.

The piece cites an interesting data point I had not seen:

And some analysts are saying an all-water route through the Panama Canal may only save about $100 per load for the whole supply chain cost.

That means, assuming the new fees for using the widened Panama Canal do not increase dramatically, that there would certainly be cost savings for shippers who would like to switch from using the West Coast to the East, but that those savings would be limited and might be offset by the extra time that ships require. Most goods could be unloaded at West Coast ports, put on eastbound trains, and arrive at their final destinations days sooner than goods that are shipped all the way the East Coast through the widened canal.

In writing about the issue of the expensive and environmentally tricky Savannah Harbor Expansion Project, I’ve regularly noted that the Corps of Engineers’ economic projections that predict growth in the number of containers handled at the Georgia ports will increase at the same rate whether the Savannah River is dredged or not.

The piece cited here is yet more reason to think that many dredging proponents have overstated the importance of deepening East Coast ports and overstated the negative effects on those East Coast harbors that are not deepened.

]]>
6068
A few photos from the Savannah National Wildlife Refuge http://www.billdawers.com/2013/07/12/a-few-photos-from-the-savannah-national-wildlife-refuge/ http://www.billdawers.com/2013/07/12/a-few-photos-from-the-savannah-national-wildlife-refuge/#comments Fri, 12 Jul 2013 23:51:51 +0000 http://www.billdawers.com/?p=5903 Read more →

]]>
In my City Talk column on Tuesday, I mentioned taking a visiting family to the Savannah National Wildlife Refuge.

Given the blustery weather, sudden squalls, and impatient boys who were along for the ride, I didn’t take very many photos, but we did see a couple of alligators pretty close and saw several anhingas in the medium distance.

I need to head over there again later this summer with my camera and take my time.

]]>
http://www.billdawers.com/2013/07/12/a-few-photos-from-the-savannah-national-wildlife-refuge/feed/ 2 5903
Savannah Morning News: City council likely to reject further cruise ship studies http://www.billdawers.com/2013/06/27/savannah-morning-news-city-council-likely-to-reject-further-cruise-ship-studies/ Thu, 27 Jun 2013 04:22:19 +0000 http://www.billdawers.com/?p=5823 Read more →

]]>

I already posted my opposition to continuing with further study of whether Savannah should build a cruise ship terminal. I think that the idea should be rejected purely on economic and political grounds, but there’s obviously a bigger argument that could be made about the incompatibility of cruise ships with the city’s broader vision of tourism and with Savannah’s relatively small scale.

It looks like the issue will die at Thursday’s City Council meeting, according to a detailed (and perhaps a bit dizzying to some) piece by Mary Landers in Thursday’s Savannah Morning News: Support for Savannah cruise terminal sinking

The last couple of paragraphs even suggest that alderman Tony Thomas, who largely is responsible for getting the city to consider the possibility of a cruise ship terminal, is backing away to some degree from the project:

Despite the likely “no” vote today, Thomas said the close to $250,000 the city paid for the studies (as well as another $80,000 from other state and local sources) was money well spent.

“One thing you can say about this task force is that it did its due diligence looking at Savannah as a possible home port,” Thomas said. “If anything the small amount of public money invested was wiser than going out and building a facility that wasn’t right, didn’t work or can’t be used. An example of that is the Hutchinson Island race track.”

]]>
5823
The question no one is asking about cruise ships in Savannah http://www.billdawers.com/2013/06/18/the-question-no-one-is-asking-about-cruise-ships-in-savannah/ Tue, 18 Jun 2013 16:05:09 +0000 http://www.billdawers.com/?p=5795 Read more →

]]>

Next week we’ll get to take a look at a study about the viability of potential sites for a cruise ship terminal in Savannah.

The study has been completed by BEA Architects, which designs such facilities, so of course the document will argue for the viability of at least one site.

I’d love to have to eat my words on that last sentence, but, really, give me a break. Click here for more on the study.

But the question that we need to be asking before we waste any more public money and civic time debating this issue isn’t about the viability of the waterfront.

We need to be talking now to the folks at the Georgia Ports Authority, the Army Corps of Engineers, and the Coast Guard (I guess they’d be the right people) about the viability of cruise ships in the same long channel that will carry an increasing amount of cargo traffic for the foreseeable future.

In fact, we’re on the verge of spending $700 million of public money on a massive economic stimulus project to increase the efficiency of private shipping companies that use the Savannah River. The deeper channel will allow larger ships and more heavily laden ships. Some vessels will no longer have to wait for higher tides before coming in from the sea.

We also have liquified natural gas (LNG) tankers that come routinely to the facility at Elba Island, and the frequency of those trips seems likely to increase too. As I understand it, river traffic is completely shut down when those tankers are in use.

So how are all these commercial interests going to react when they find out that cruise ships on relatively tight schedules have to use the Savannah River at specific times?

It seems sort of ridiculous to spend $700 million in large measure to speed up freight traffic and then turn around and lure cruise ships that seem likely to dramatically slow that traffic.

So before we get too deep into all this, it’s time for the folks at the Georgia Ports Authority to get involved in the discussion.

]]>
5795
World Ocean School on the Roseway schooner now docked in Savannah (photos) http://www.billdawers.com/2013/04/21/world-ocean-school-on-the-roseway-schooner-now-docked-in-savannah/ Sun, 21 Apr 2013 14:39:49 +0000 http://www.billdawers.com/?p=5448 Read more →

]]>

My City Talk column in the Savannah Morning News today, Historic schooner offers educational programs, day sails on Savannah River, discusses my cruise last week on the Roseway, a tall ship now home to the World Ocean School.

If the Roseway continues to come to Savannah each spring and fall, there’s incredible potential for both educational opportunities and tourism.

Read the column for more.

Here, I just have some photos I took.

As you can see, it was quite sunny and clear when we left the Westin dock a little after 5 p.m., but quickly turned blustery and cloudy. As a consequence, we never raised all the sails.

I was struck by the hard work that the crew must put in. Young adults getting paid very little, they instruct school groups on many weekdays, have to answer the endless questions of tourists on recreational sails like the one I took, and also live on the boat.

In the column, I mention some of the architectural features that one can see in sharp relief from the river. A few of those elements are here in these photos.

Click for larger versions.

]]>
5448
Just $1.28 million in Obama budget for Savannah port dredging http://www.billdawers.com/2013/04/10/just-1-28-million-in-obama-budget-for-savannah-port-dredging/ Wed, 10 Apr 2013 19:13:18 +0000 http://www.billdawers.com/?p=5392 Read more →

]]>

I haven’t been posting much to the statewide political blog Peach Pundit over the last few weeks.

But I have a new post up right now: Despite significant infrastructure spending in Obama’s proposed budget, only a pittance for Savannah port expansion

This is a very interesting development, and it leaves the Republican-dominated Georgia congressional delegation with the tricky task of coming up with over $400 million in federal funding.

]]>
5392